Why Should I Buy Seafood from City Seafood Instead of the Grocery Store? - City Seafood

Why Should I Buy Seafood from City Seafood Instead of the Grocery Store?

Jul 31, 2026
by
My Store Admin

When it comes to buying seafood, many people assume all fish is the same. In reality, where you buy your seafood can make a big difference in freshness, selection, convenience, and quality.

Here are some of the questions we hear most often.


Is City Seafood fresher than grocery store seafood?

In many cases, yes.

At City Seafood, seafood is our specialty. We source premium, restaurant-quality seafood from trusted suppliers and focus on getting it from the dock to your doorstep as quickly as possible. Every order is carefully packed and kept cold to maintain freshness.

Many grocery stores carry excellent seafood, but their seafood department is just one small part of a much larger operation. Depending on inventory and demand, seafood may spend more time in display cases before it's purchased.


Is your seafood restaurant quality?

Absolutely.

Many local restaurants and country clubs trust City Seafood for their seafood because of our quality standards. The same premium seafood supplied to our wholesale customers is also available to families throughout the St. Louis area.


Why doesn't City Seafood have a traditional seafood counter?

Our business is designed around online ordering and free local delivery.

Instead of standing at a seafood case hoping the item you want is available, you can browse our full selection online, build your order, and either have it delivered or pick it up at our Fenton location.


Do you carry seafood I can't find at my local grocery store?

Often, yes.

In addition to customer favorites like salmon, shrimp, scallops, lobster tails, and crab, City Seafood regularly offers specialty fish and seasonal selections that aren't commonly stocked by traditional grocery stores.

Our inventory changes throughout the year based on quality and seasonal availability, giving customers access to a wider variety of premium seafood.


Is frozen seafood bad?

Not at all.

Many people are surprised to learn that some seafood is actually best when professionally frozen shortly after harvest. Flash freezing helps preserve freshness, flavor, and texture.

Some of our products are fresh, while others are frozen because that's the best way to deliver the highest quality. The important thing isn't whether it's fresh or frozen. It's how quickly and properly it's handled.


Is seafood from City Seafood more expensive?

Not necessarily.

While premium seafood can cost more than some grocery store options, customers are often surprised by how competitive our prices are, especially considering the quality, convenience, and free local delivery.

Many customers find they receive better value because they're purchasing restaurant-quality seafood without restaurant markups.


Can I order exactly what I want?

Yes.

You can build your own custom seafood box by choosing exactly the products and quantities you want.

Whether you're cooking dinner for two, stocking your freezer, or planning a party, you're never limited to prepackaged bundles.


How is my seafood delivered?

Every order is packed carefully, insulated, and kept cold throughout delivery.

Our complimentary local delivery service brings your seafood directly to your home, making it easy to enjoy premium seafood without making another stop after work.


Why do so many St. Louis families choose City Seafood?

Our customers appreciate the combination of:

  • Restaurant-quality seafood
  • Premium selection
  • Convenient online ordering
  • Free local delivery
  • Friendly local service
  • Helpful recipes and cooking tips
  • Flexible pickup option

Our goal is simple: make it easy for families to enjoy incredible seafood at home.


Is ordering online difficult?

Not at all.

We've designed our online ordering process to be quick and simple. Browse your favorite seafood, add the items you'd like to your cart, choose delivery or pickup, and check out in just a few minutes.

Whether you're ordering from your phone, tablet, or computer, building your custom seafood box is easy.


Why choose City Seafood over the grocery store?

At City Seafood, seafood isn't just one department in a large store—it's everything we do.

Our team is passionate about sourcing premium seafood, providing exceptional customer service, and making it easy for families throughout the St. Louis area to enjoy restaurant-quality seafood at home.

From our carefully selected products to our free local delivery, every part of our business is built around delivering a better seafood experience.


Ready to Taste the Difference?

Whether you're grilling salmon, pan-searing scallops, steaming lobster tails, or trying something new, City Seafood makes it easy to bring restaurant-quality seafood home.

Browse our selection, build your custom seafood box, and enjoy free local delivery throughout the St. Louis area.

Drop us a line

Rectangle 22.svg__PID:3fb5c3e3-3b41-4e7b-86ad-99fb588806f1Rectangle 22.svg__PID:3fb5c3e3-3b41-4e7b-86ad-99fb588806f1

Send a message